For months now, we've been avid fans of CoverGirl 's LashBlast For ages c in depth mascara—a totally natural-looking, 100% clump-free, perfect-for-everyday lash enhancer. But lately, we've been craving something a only slightly more dramatic—and our skinny eyelashes were hankering for some plumping. The problem? So many combo volumizing/lengthening mascaras we've tried give us spiky, clumpy, gloopy looking eyelashes—stuck-together lashes so messed up that even a scourge comb couldn't help. We chalk it up to mascara formulas, over the last few years, trending towards the glossy—and, therefore, a "wetter" consistency.